I'll go with scholar--because that's what i play in real life--but I don't know as much as the true band scholars do. Definitely not a collector, but have some traits. I saw a vision of that road when a guy I knew once paid $10 for a copy of some b/w photo of John Lennon. The clerk, after my friend walked away just shook his head. So while I can get obsessive--just nought 2 Pink Floyd records today because of the doc i saw last week--I don't HAVE to have a t-shirt or poster (but I wouldn't turn them down, either).